Your protocol has 41 security issues — 3 Critical, 13 High, 9 Medium, 16 Low severity.
Security Overview //
Security Overview
Access Control
Vulnerable
14 finding(s) — includes critical severity
Reentrancy Protection
Needs Attention
3 finding(s) — medium/low severity
Oracle Security
Vulnerable
1 finding(s) — includes high severity
Upgrade Safety
Secure
Input Validation
Vulnerable
16 finding(s) — includes high severity
Event Logging
Needs Attention
10 finding(s) — medium/low severity
Severity Breakdown
Vulnerability Breakdown
Below is a comprehensive breakdown of the vulnerabilities discovered in your smart contracts. As part of our marketing outreach, we expose the highest-severity vulnerability for free.
Missing access control on `transfer()`
cryptokitties.sol:57
Impact
An attacker could call `transfer()` to perform privileged actions such as draining funds, minting tokens, or changing contract configuration.
Description
The sensitive function `transfer` is external but has no access control modifier (e.g., onlyOwner, onlyRole) or inline msg.sender check. Anyone can call this function.
Vulnerable Code
55 54 | function balanceOf(address _owner) public view returns (uint256 balance);56 55 | function ownerOf(uint256 _tokenId) external view returns (address owner);57 56 | function approve(address _to, uint256 _tokenId) external;58 >>> 57 | function transfer(address _to, uint256 _tokenId) external;59 58 | function transferFrom(address _from, address _to, uint256 _tokenId) external;60 59 |61 60 | // Events
Recommendation
Add an access control modifier like `onlyOwner` or use OpenZeppelin's `AccessControl` to restrict who can call `transfer()`.
40 More Issues Detected
The following findings require expert review for full remediation guidance.
Missing access control on `unpause()`
The sensitive function `unpause` is public but has no access control modifier (e.g., onlyOwner, onlyRole) or inline msg.sender check. Anyone can call this function.
Add an access control modifier like `onlyOwner` or use OpenZeppelin's `AccessControl` to restrict who can call `unpause()`.
Missing access control on `unpause()`
The sensitive function `unpause` is public but has no access control modifier (e.g., onlyOwner, onlyRole) or inline msg.sender check. Anyone can call this function.
Add an access control modifier like `onlyOwner` or use OpenZeppelin's `AccessControl` to restrict who can call `unpause()`.
Unchecked `.send()` return value
The return value of `.send()` at line 1063 is not checked. Low-level calls return a boolean indicating success or failure, which must be verified.
Capture and check the return value: `(bool success, ) = addr.send(...); require(success, "Call failed");`
Unchecked `.send()` return value
The return value of `.send()` at line 2010 is not checked. Low-level calls return a boolean indicating success or failure, which must be verified.
Capture and check the return value: `(bool success, ) = addr.send(...); require(success, "Call failed");`
Unprotected arithmetic (`-`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 412 performs `-` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`-`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 634 performs `-` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`-=`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 686 performs `-=` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`+=`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 690 performs `+=` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`+=`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 691 performs `+=` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`-`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 695 performs `-` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`+`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 796 performs `+` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`+=`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 802 performs `+=` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`-`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 1049 performs `-` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
Unprotected arithmetic (`+`) in pre-0.8.0 contract
Line 1053 performs `+` arithmetic in a Solidity <0.8.0 contract without SafeMath. This can silently overflow or underflow.
Use OpenZeppelin's SafeMath library for all arithmetic operations, or upgrade to Solidity >=0.8.0 which has built-in overflow checks.
`balanceOf()` used in arithmetic (potential price oracle)
Line 328 uses `balanceOf()` in an arithmetic expression, which may derive a spot price that is manipulable via flash loans.
Use TWAP or Chainlink oracles instead of spot balance calculations.
Missing reentrancy guard on `giveBirth`
Function `giveBirth` contains external calls but lacks a `nonReentrant` modifier. While it may follow CEI, a guard provides defense-in-depth.
Add OpenZeppelin's `ReentrancyGuard` and apply `nonReentrant` to functions with external calls.
Missing reentrancy guard on `withdrawBalance`
Function `withdrawBalance` contains external calls but lacks a `nonReentrant` modifier. While it may follow CEI, a guard provides defense-in-depth.
Add OpenZeppelin's `ReentrancyGuard` and apply `nonReentrant` to functions with external calls.
Missing reentrancy guard on `withdrawBalance`
Function `withdrawBalance` contains external calls but lacks a `nonReentrant` modifier. While it may follow CEI, a guard provides defense-in-depth.
Add OpenZeppelin's `ReentrancyGuard` and apply `nonReentrant` to functions with external calls.
`bid()` lacks slippage and deadline protection
Function `bid` at line 1449 appears to perform a swap/trade operation but has no slippage protection (minAmountOut) or deadline parameter. This makes it highly vulnerable to sandwich attacks and MEV extraction.
Add a `minAmountOut` or equivalent slippage parameter and a `deadline` parameter. Validate both with require statements.
`bid()` lacks slippage and deadline protection
Function `bid` at line 1577 appears to perform a swap/trade operation but has no slippage protection (minAmountOut) or deadline parameter. This makes it highly vulnerable to sandwich attacks and MEV extraction.
Add a `minAmountOut` or equivalent slippage parameter and a `deadline` parameter. Validate both with require statements.
`bid()` lacks slippage and deadline protection
Function `bid` at line 1647 appears to perform a swap/trade operation but has no slippage protection (minAmountOut) or deadline parameter. This makes it highly vulnerable to sandwich attacks and MEV extraction.
Add a `minAmountOut` or equivalent slippage parameter and a `deadline` parameter. Validate both with require statements.
`bidOnSiringAuction()` lacks slippage and deadline protection
Function `bidOnSiringAuction` at line 1773 appears to perform a swap/trade operation but has no slippage protection (minAmountOut) or deadline parameter. This makes it highly vulnerable to sandwich attacks and MEV extraction.
Add a `minAmountOut` or equivalent slippage parameter and a `deadline` parameter. Validate both with require statements.
Locked Ether: contract receives Ether but lacks withdrawal function
Contract `SiringClockAuction` is designed to receive Ether (it defines payable functions, `receive()`, or `fallback()`), but it has no visible function to withdraw or transfer Ether back out. Any Ether sent to this contract will be permanently locked and unrecoverable.
Implement a secure administrative withdrawal function (e.g. `withdraw()`) restricted to the contract owner/admin that transfers the contract's balance to an authorized address.
Locked Ether: contract receives Ether but lacks withdrawal function
Contract `SaleClockAuction` is designed to receive Ether (it defines payable functions, `receive()`, or `fallback()`), but it has no visible function to withdraw or transfer Ether back out. Any Ether sent to this contract will be permanently locked and unrecoverable.
Implement a secure administrative withdrawal function (e.g. `withdraw()`) restricted to the contract owner/admin that transfers the contract's balance to an authorized address.
Floating pragma: `pragma solidity ^0.4.11`
The Solidity version pragma `^0.4.11` is not locked to a specific compiler version. Different compiler versions may introduce different behavior, optimizations, or bugs.
Lock the pragma to a specific version, e.g., `pragma solidity 0.8.20;`. Use the latest stable version for new contracts.
State-changing function `setCEO` does not emit an event
The function `setCEO` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `setCFO` does not emit an event
The function `setCFO` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `setCOO` does not emit an event
The function `setCOO` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `pause` does not emit an event
The function `pause` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `unpause` does not emit an event
The function `unpause` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `setSecondsPerBlock` does not emit an event
The function `setSecondsPerBlock` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `setMetadataAddress` does not emit an event
The function `setMetadataAddress` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `setGeneScienceAddress` does not emit an event
The function `setGeneScienceAddress` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `approveSiring` does not emit an event
The function `approveSiring` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
State-changing function `setAutoBirthFee` does not emit an event
The function `setAutoBirthFee` is public/external and mutates state variables, but it does not emit any events. Emitting events is a standard security practice in Solidity to facilitate off-chain tracking, indexing, and security monitoring.
Define an event and emit it at the end of the state-changing operations in this function, passing relevant arguments (like old and new values).
Timestamp dependence in `if` condition
Line 1253 uses `block.timestamp` inside an `if` condition. Since block.timestamp can be slightly manipulated by miners, using it in critical control structures carries a minor security risk.
Use block numbers for coarse time estimation if appropriate, or ensure the design accommodates a timestamp variance of up to 15 minutes.
Missing zero-address check for parameter `_owner`
Function or constructor `tokensOfOwner` accepts address parameter `_owner` but does not validate if it is the zero address (`address(0)`). Setting critical state variables or roles to the zero address by mistake can cause loss of ownership, permanently locked contracts, or unexpected resets.
Add a require statement or validation check: `require(_owner != address(0), "Invalid address");` at the beginning of the function.
Missing zero-address check for parameter `_nftAddress`
Function or constructor `ClockAuction` accepts address parameter `_nftAddress` but does not validate if it is the zero address (`address(0)`). Setting critical state variables or roles to the zero address by mistake can cause loss of ownership, permanently locked contracts, or unexpected resets.
Add a require statement or validation check: `require(_nftAddress != address(0), "Invalid address");` at the beginning of the function.
Missing zero-address check for parameter `_nftAddr`
Function or constructor `SiringClockAuction` accepts address parameter `_nftAddr` but does not validate if it is the zero address (`address(0)`). Setting critical state variables or roles to the zero address by mistake can cause loss of ownership, permanently locked contracts, or unexpected resets.
Add a require statement or validation check: `require(_nftAddr != address(0), "Invalid address");` at the beginning of the function.
Missing zero-address check for parameter `_nftAddr`
Function or constructor `SaleClockAuction` accepts address parameter `_nftAddr` but does not validate if it is the zero address (`address(0)`). Setting critical state variables or roles to the zero address by mistake can cause loss of ownership, permanently locked contracts, or unexpected resets.
Add a require statement or validation check: `require(_nftAddr != address(0), "Invalid address");` at the beginning of the function.
Our automated scan found 41 issues. Our expert auditors go deeper — covering logic bugs, economic attack vectors, and cross-contract interactions that automated tools miss.
Or email us at audit@0xram.com (Contact form is preferred for priority review)
Secure Your Protocol
Before Launch
This automated scan is just the surface. Our team of expert auditors conducts line-by-line manual reviews, formal verification, and economic simulations to ensure your protocol is battle-tested.
Or email us at audit@0xram.com (Contact form preferred for priority queueing)